Canada’s Parliament handed a movement this week unanimously declaring that the far-right extremist Proud Boys needs to be designated a terrorist group, within the wake of the Jan. 6 revolt on the U.S. Capitol. It has turn into more and more clear that the Proud Boys performed a central position in that violence. At least six members of the group, together with one among its most outstanding, have been arrested within the U.S. in reference to the riot.
The Canadian legislature’s largely symbolic transfer just isn’t a proper designation, regardless of some viral tweets and news headlines suggesting the opposite. But extremism consultants are involved that it truly units a harmful precedent.
Canada has considerably broad standards for what constitutes a terrorist group, and maybe the Proud Boys would match the definition. Extremism researchers and Canadian nationwide safety consultants are anxious, nevertheless, that the movement dangers politicizing a delicate course of supposed to be dealt with exterior Parliament whereas doing little to truly confront the specter of far-right extremism in that nation.
Canada’s terrorism listings are determined by a course of through which federal regulation enforcement, intelligence businesses and the Canadian Department of Public Safety evaluate proof of terrorist exercise. This Monday’s movement deviates from that course of, searching for to strain the businesses and the general public security minister to “immediately” designate the Proud Boys as terrorists.
“The enforcement of criminal law and criminal law sanctions should be arm’s length from politics,” mentioned Leah West, an assistant professor at Carleton University in Ottawa who was previously concerned within the terrorism itemizing course of on the Canadian Department of Justice.
“We might all agree that the Proud Boys engage in acts of violence that we all deem reprehensible,” West mentioned, “but it’s a slippery slope and a bad precedent for politicians who are seeking to curry favor with a certain segment of the population to be deciding who is and isn’t a terrorist under the criminal code.”
There are additionally issues that fast-tracking the terrorist designation course of or loosening its requirements beneath political strain may open the door to future abuse, doubtlessly changing into a method for conservatives to focus on protests they dislike, such because the blockades of energy pipelines by Indigenous and environmental activists final 12 months.
“We don’t want those criteria being glossed over or loosened because that has the potential to rebound on anti-racist and BIPOC groups. It wasn’t long ago that some MPs called for Indigenous land defenders to be designated as terrorists,” mentioned Evan Balgord, govt director of the Canadian Anti-Hate Network, which displays extremism.
In the U.S., then-President Donald Trump as soon as threatened to listing anti-fascist activists as terrorists (though authorized consultants doubted he may).
“I’m concerned that we might have taken a page out of the Trump administration’s book of using listing as a means to condemn,” West mentioned.
What This Could Mean For The Proud Boys
When Canada designates a terrorist group, the rapid penalties for the listed group are largely monetary: Monetary transactions with the group are blocked, authorities can seize property held in Canada and personal companies acquire a broad mandate to disclaim providers.
What may occur to particular person Proud Boys if the group finally ends up on Canada’s listing is much less outlined. A terrorist designation wouldn’t outright criminalize membership, however it will enable monetary establishments to terminate members’ financial institution accounts and make fundraising tougher by denying them providers. It may additionally imply that Canadian border authorities refuse entry to recognized Proud Boys and that prosecutors cost Canadians sending cash to the group with offering monetary assist for a terrorist group.
Canada units a number of vaguely outlined standards to fulfill the edge for a terrorist itemizing. The group has to pose a critical menace of violence that goes past easy property harm or bodily altercations. It should intend to commit violence with the objective of intimidating a sure part of the inhabitants or one other political group. Finally, the group have to be pushed by an ideological motivation, which within the Proud Boys case would seemingly be its misogynist, white nationalist and fascist beliefs.
Canada has its personal ties to the Proud Boys. Founder Gavin McInnes is a Canadian citizen, and chapters of the group are lively throughout the nation. In 2017, 5 members of the Canadian army who had been additionally concerned with the Proud Boys disrupted an Indigenous rights protest. The army reinstated the service members to lively responsibility after a short suspension.
The Proud Boys are much less lively in Canada than within the U.S., nevertheless, and final 12 months a part of the Canadian membership splintered off to create Canada First, a neo-Nazi group.
Experts have identified that there are quite a few different far-right extremist teams with in depth ties to Canada that characterize equal or better terror threats within the nation and argued that addressing Canada’s white nationalist drawback requires a broader strategy than merely including extra names to a listing.
Public Safety Minister Bill Blair mentioned that he’ll seek the advice of with intelligence businesses earlier than deciding on what motion to take towards the Proud Boys. Canada’s terrorist itemizing course of has beforehand positioned an emphasis on Islamist terrorist teams. Only two far-right teams have been added to the listing to this point, even because the worldwide menace of far-right extremism has grown.
Calling all HuffPost superfans!
Sign up for membership to turn into a founding member and assist form HuffPost’s subsequent chapter