In October 2019, Rep. Deb Haaland (D-N.M.) led a House subcommittee hearing on the results of anti-government extremism on federal land administration officers. The Government Accountability Office had not too long ago documented greater than 350 incidents of threats and assaults concentrating on land administration workers between 2013 and 2017.
As the watchdog group famous, even that knowledge didn’t seize the total image, partially as a result of not all incidents are reported. Some officers advised investigators they “consider receiving threats a normal part of their job.”
Haaland, then in her first congressional time period, harassed that these “extremist ideologies did not develop in a vacuum.” She learn aloud a quote from former Sen. Dean Heller (R-Nev.) on the 2014 armed standoff between federal brokers and militias at Nevada rancher Cliven Bundy’s ranch, through which Heller praised the militiamen as “patriots.” And she famous that Nevada state Rep. Michele Fiore had supported the armed militants who took management of Malheur National Wildlife Refuge in Oregon in 2016. Fiore, a Republican, dismissed the Bureau of Land Management on the time as “a bureaucratic agency of basically terrorism.”
Now, Haaland is about to take the reins of the Interior Department. A Senate committee superior her nomination Thursday, and he or she is anticipated to get a closing vote inside the subsequent few weeks. She would make historical past as the primary Native American Cabinet secretary, and the primary Native American to steer the federal company that employs greater than 70,000 folks, manages 500 million acres of federal land — roughly a fifth of the U.S. — and units insurance policies for pure useful resource extraction.
As the brand new administration is available in and tries to implement guidelines, there’s the potential for violence on a larger scale.
Betsy Gaines Quammen, creator
Haaland’s ascent comes at a very risky second, within the wake of a violent Capitol revolt that included members of most of the similar anti-government militia teams which have waged warfare on the Interior Department. And it comes after 4 years of the Trump administration, which coddled anti-federal land zealots and prioritized pure useful resource extraction over all else.
All of this has public land advocates and specialists who monitor far-right teams frightened concerning the danger of armed battle between federal businesses and anti-government militias.
Steve Pedery, conservation director at Oregon Wild, expects Haaland will probably be examined early. “It’s unfortunate, but I guarantee we’ll see the Bundys pull something again,” he mentioned.
In truth, Bundy has already threatened violence. In an interview in January, days earlier than President Joe Biden’s inauguration, Bundy warned that he and his allies would “walk forward towards guns” if the brand new administration tried to gather long-overdue grazing charges and spherical up his cattle. That’s what the Obama administration tried unsuccessfully to do in 2014. Bundy has now been grazing his cattle illegally on public lands for over 20 years.
Bundy additionally praised the violent mob of Donald Trump supporters who stormed the Capitol on Jan. 6 in an try and overturn the outcomes of the 2020 election. On Facebook, Bundy wrote that “you can’t clean the swamp by standing off at a distance and smelling it” — a nod to Trump’s marketing campaign claims that he would “drain the swamp” of particular pursuits in Washington.
Aaron Weiss, deputy director of the Colorado-based conservation group Center for Western Priorities, worries the powder keg is now simply ready for a lightweight.
“I do think it’s not an if, but a when,” he mentioned.
An Emboldened Movement
Trump’s 4 years in workplace drastically empowered anti-government extremists.
His Interior Department repeatedly hosted individuals who wish to see federal lands offered off. Fierce critics of endangered species protections and federal land administration had been tapped for highly effective division posts. William Perry Pendley, a conservative lawyer with excessive anti-environmental views who spent his profession lobbying for the sale of federal lands, was put in control of Interior’s Bureau of Land Management.
Trump issued pardons for folks like Utah state Rep. Phil Lyman (R) ― who in 2014 led anti-federal land protesters on an unlawful ATV journey on public lands that had been off limits to off-road automobiles ― and Dwight Lincoln Hammond Jr. and Steven Hammond, the father-son Oregon ranchers whose arson conviction preceded the armed takeover of the Malheur refuge.
On the ultimate day of Trump’s presidency, then-Interior Secretary David Bernhardt restored the Hammonds’ grazing allow, which was revoked after the 2 males had been convicted of deliberately setting fireplace to federal land.
Along with pardoning a few of their prison exercise, Trump at instances applauded violent radicals, together with the pro-Trump insurrectionists who stormed the Capitol, as “patriots.”
On the flip aspect, Trump administration officers derided environmentalists as home extremists. Ryan Zinke, Trump’s first inside secretary, blamed “environmental terrorist groups” for catastrophic wildfires in the West. And a long time earlier than becoming a member of the Trump administration, Pendley and his group, the Mountain States Legal Foundation, arrange a hotline for the general public to report “acts of environmental terrorism” and held conferences on “eco-terrorism,” as HuffPost beforehand reported. Pendley was as soon as a key determine of the so-called “Wise-Use movement,” a gaggle of anti-government organizations that gained momentum within the Eighties and pushed to spice up mining, drilling and logging on federal lands, vilifying environmentalists alongside the way in which.
The Biden administration has vowed to place public lands to make use of because it pursues aggressive federal motion to fight the local weather and extinction crises. It has issued a slew of early govt orders, which amongst different issues briefly paused new oil and gasoline leasing on federal lands and waters and canceled a key allow for the Keystone XL oil pipeline. It additionally set a aim of defending 30% of America’s lands and waters by 2030, an effort that’s anticipated to kick off with Biden restoring protected websites that his predecessor dismantled, together with the Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante nationwide monuments in southern Utah.
Biden’s environmental agenda has infuriated lawmakers from fossil fuel-producing states, and will finally collide with extremist organizations just like the Oath Keepers and Three Percenters, two of the militia teams that flocked to the Bundy ranch in 2014, to Malheur in 2016 and to the Capitol riot in January. Both teams have long records of threatening violence in opposition to public land officers within the West, and a DeSmog investigation final yr revealed that quite a few Three Percenters members work in oil fields in numerous Western states.
“As the new administration comes in and tries to enforce rules, there’s the potential for violence on a greater scale,” mentioned Montana creator Betsy Gaines Quammen, who revealed a guide final yr on the Bundy household and the spiritual roots of the anti-public lands motion.
Republicans whose campaigns are bankrolled in no small half by extractive industries have turned to some acquainted rhetoric to assault Haaland. GOP senators together with Steve Daines (Mont.), who has a historical past of railing in opposition to what he calls “fringe environmental extremists,” have painted Haaland as a “far-left ideologue” and “radical” risk to the American “way of life,” citing her help for the Green New Deal and former statements opposing hydraulic fracturing, oil pipelines and new fossil gas leasing on federal lands.
“It is interesting to me how much of the opposition to her is inextricably linked to the fact that she’s an Indigenous woman, and that opponents assume that if she is confirmed and advocates for Indigenous interests on public lands, it would automatically be bad for them,” mentioned Pedery, of Oregon Wild. “Kind of a tacit acknowledgement that the exploitation of public lands for logging, oil and gas, mining and cattle in the Western U.S. over the last 150 years is inextricably linked with a history of racism and genocide against Indigenous people.”
Flashes From The Past
Right-wing teams are already busy producing opposition and outrage to Haaland on-line.
On MeWe, a social media platform the place extremists and conspiracy theorists are rampant, a consumer not too long ago circulated a publish from the group Montana & Conservative Values about how Daines had uncovered Haaland’s “hostility to Western energy jobs and industry.” In actuality, throughout her affirmation listening to, Haaland advised Daines and different lawmakers she’d battle for fossil gas employees, that she understood the significance of oil and gasoline income to funding group providers, and that “fossil energy does and will continue to play a major role in America for years to come.”
Elsewhere, of us like Sam Faddis, a former CIA agent and 2018 Republican Senate candidate, have peddled a conspiracy theory that the Communist Party of China might have hand-picked Haaland for the publish.
More broadly, not less than one of many Biden Interior Department’s early actions has garnered the eye of gun rights teams and the far proper. Last week, the company rescinded the Trump administration’s Eleventh-hour choice to revive the Hammonds’ grazing permits.
“The Left simply cannot wait for more bloodshed,” the Oregon Firearms Federation, a pro-gun group, wrote in a MeWe publish that linked to The Oregonian’s protection of the allow revocation.
The information additionally sparked outrage on the non-public Facebook web page of Timber Unity, an anti-environmental group with logging business funding and ties to militia groups and different extremists. Members of Timber Unity chimed in beneath a publish to ask “How much longer until we stand up and fight?” and to remark “Is anyone surprised. 2A” (a reference to the Second Amendment), in keeping with screenshots shared with HuffPost.
When a difficulty beneficial properties traction with the Second Amendment crowd, it’s usually a primary step towards a bigger mobilization of the so-called Patriot motion, mentioned Hampton Stall, a senior researcher on the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project and founding father of Militia Watch, which tracks the militia motion and far-right ideologies.
Over the previous yr, this motion has been busy confronting the Black Lives Matter protesters, throwing matches over COVID-19 masks mandates and different pandemic restrictions, plotting to kidnap Michigan’s Democratic governor over the state’s coronavirus lockdown and, in fact, trying to violently overturn the 2020 presidential election. But because the armed standoffs on the Bundy ranch and Malheur confirmed, armed militias are at all times searching for the following problem or occasion to rally behind — a phenomenon that extremism specialists name “cause shopping.”
In Oregon, which is house to a thriving militia motion, the far proper tends to mobilize round public land and environmental points “in part because that’s where the [financial] support and political legitimacy for them come from,” Pedery mentioned. Two a long time in the past, militia teams descended on Klamath Falls to help farmers of their feud with the federal authorities, which on the time blocked farmers from accessing irrigation water so as to guard endangered suckerfish habitat.
And in 2015, months earlier than the Malheur occupation, a dispute between two gold miners and the Bureau of Land Management led to an armed standoff that lasted for weeks. The Oath Keepers had been key gamers in that episode, which, as The Oregonian reported, helped impress the militia motion.
John Temple, creator of “Up in Arms: How the Bundy Family Hijacked Public Lands, Outfoxed the Federal Government, and Ignited America’s Patriot Militia Movement,” advised HuffPost the Biden administration doubtless has some critical challenges forward when it comes to advancing its environmental and public lands targets. Certain individuals are going to really feel they’ve been trampled by the administration’s insurance policies, he mentioned.
As for the potential of an armed standoff arising, Temple famous, it might rely upon whether or not a sure problem is diminished to a easy bumper sticker or a face to rally behind. With the Bundys, it was the federal government coming to remove the cattle of a rugged individualist rancher. With the election, it was the false narrative that the vote had been rigged and Trump’s rightful victory stolen.
As Temple sees it, the panorama at this time could be very completely different than it was throughout the Bundy standoff in 2014. Whereas then a mob of individuals taking over arms in opposition to federal officers “seemed like an atrocity,” now it “feels sort of inevitable,” he mentioned.
Adding to the strain, Ammon Bundy, Cliven’s son who led the armed occupation at Malheur, has spent the previous yr building up a vast network of militia members and different far-right radicals to battle COVID-19 mandates.
He and different leaders of the group, often called People’s Rights, have made obscure warnings a few looming battle, telling members to arrange for “the force that is evident to come upon us,” the Idaho Press reported in December.
“I think it’s just a matter of time before some of these folks start to pivot away from COVID-19 organizing and focus their attention on the Bureau of Land Management yet again,” mentioned Stephen Piggott, a researcher with the Portland, Oregon-based nonprofit Western States Center. “I could see a lot of this stuff coming to a head in the near future.”
A Radical Road Ahead
With Haaland poised to imagine management of the 172-year-old Interior Department, specialists and advocates say coping with this home risk would require further assets and a unique legislation enforcement response.
“Exacerbated by new political polarization and by Trump, right-wing armed groups have been mobilizing and gaining an increased sense of impunity since the 1990s,” Vanda Felbab-Brown, director of the Brookings Institution’s Initiative on Nonstate Armed Actors, wrote in a January piece on countering right-wing armed teams. She famous that “the government’s leniency toward the anti-federal-government Bundy group” throughout the Malheur takeover additional “emboldened” such teams.
While greater than a dozen contributors within the Malheur occupation pleaded guilty to criminal charges, and 4 had been convicted by a federal jury, Ammon Bundy and 6 different leaders had been finally acquitted. In 2018, a choose additionally declared a mistrial and dismissed all fees in opposition to Cliven Bundy and his sons stemming from the 2014 standoff on the household ranch in Bunkerville, Nevada.
“There have to be consequences and above all else, you can’t give these folks the microphone,” Weiss mentioned. “Letting them turn it into a media circus, letting them hold press conferences, giving them a megaphone to amplify their anti-public land message was a huge mistake. That cannot happen again.”
In a current podcast interview with the Center for Western Priorities, former Interior Secretary Sally Jewell, who led the company by way of each incidents, defended the federal government’s choice to again down throughout the 2014 standoff on the Bundy ranch, saying it was the one technique to keep away from bloodshed. At the identical time, she acknowledged errors within the authorities prosecution.
It’s unlucky, however I assure we’ll see the Bundys pull one thing once more.
Steve Pedery, conservation director, Oregon Wild
“Until we dish out the consequences that they deserve for this kind of activity, we are just emboldening a group of well-armed, ideologically extreme people that will continue to provide a domestic terrorism problem until they are brought to justice,” Jewell mentioned. “This is a very risky time for the United States, and what we witnessed on Jan. 6 [at the Capitol] is just a small taste of what this group is interested, frankly, in dishing out.”
Haaland’s workplace declined to be quoted for this story. The Interior Department advised HuffPost it’s making strides to implement the suggestions in GAO’s 2019 report, which referred to as on federal land administration businesses, together with BLM, the Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Park Service, in addition to USDA’s Forest Service, to take steps to evaluate and handle ongoing safety dangers. BLM, for instance, has employed a full-time safety specialist to satisfy GAO’s suggestions.
“Interior is taking concrete steps to strengthen security protocols and mitigate the risks our employees face, including law enforcement who are on the frontline of protecting the public, our staff, our facilities and millions of acres of federal public lands,” Jennifer Van der Heide, Interior’s chief of employees, mentioned in an announcement.
Rep. Raúl Grijalva (D-Ariz.), chair of the House Natural Resources Committee, which has oversight of the Interior Department, advised HuffPost that the committee seems ahead to working with Haaland and the remainder of the Biden administration to search out methods to handle anti-government extremism.
“The whole country has already seen the terrible things that happen when this kind of talk turns into action,” Grijalva mentioned in an e-mail. “The Biden transition is a perfect time for the Interior Department and its agencies to take stock of their security needs, make the appropriate requests of Congress, and spend time with stakeholders to assess the risks they face in a new political world.”
Calling all HuffPost superfans!
Sign up for membership to turn into a founding member and assist form HuffPost’s subsequent chapter